RNW - NEWS, ANALYSIS AND BACKGROUND IN 10 LANGUAGES, WORLDWIDE 24 HOURS A DAY, ON RADIO, TELEVISION AND THE INTERNET

Radio Netherlands Worldwide

Home
Sea Shepherd ship Steve Irwin in action - photo: Sea Shepherd
Willemien Groot's picture
Map
The Hague, Netherlands
The Hague, Netherlands

Sea Shepherd could lose Dutch flag

Published on : 10 November 2009 - 6:22pm | By Willemien Groot
Filed under:

International environmental organisation Sea Shepherd could lose one of its most important weapons in its battle against whaling. The organisation’s flag ship sails under the Dutch flag, but a Dutch cabinet member is fed up with the situation. Deputy Transport Minister Tineke Huizinga says Sea Shepherd is endangering relations with Japan. If she gets her way, the environmental organisation will lose its Dutch flag.

See (Japanese) footage below:

Antarctica, 6 February 2009. The Japanese harpoon ship Ushin Maru 3 has just shot dead a minke whale and wants to get it to the factory ship Nishin Maru as quickly as possible. The whaler is being pursued by Sea Shepherd' protest ship Steve Irwin. The two ships collide. The crews throw missiles at each other.
 
According to Geert Vons, general director of Sea Shepherd Netherlands, the organisation takes action because no-one else does:
 
"I don't think Sea Shepherd uses violence. But what I would like to say is that under international laws and regulations many animals are protected, but in reality they are not. And this whaling issue is a very strong example. Japan is whaling within the borders of an internationally recognised sanctuary, established by the International Whaling Commission in 1994. Sea Shepherd tries to prevent the Japanese vessels from killing whales illegally."
 
Diplomatic pressure
Sea Shepherd’s protests against Canadian seal hunters, poachers and Japanese whalers are confrontational. In Canada, a second protest ship is under arrest for hampering the annual seal hunt.
 
In The Hague, the deputy transport minister has had enough of the Sea Shepherd’s flag ship sailing under the respectable Dutch flag. She wants the Ship's Certificates Registry Act changed. If a ship, sailing under a Dutch flag damages another ship or endangers diplomatic relations, it should no longer be allowed to sail under that flag.

According to Professor Fred Soons, maritime law expert, the Netherlands has no alternative:
 
"Japan is supposed to exercise effective control over their ships and to prevent them from engaging in unlawful activities. Just as the Netherlands has to exercise its effective control as the state under whose flag the Sea Shepherd’s ships sail. That is an obligation of international law."
 
Scientific research
Japan says it hunts whales for scientific research. Around 1000 minke whales, blue whales and sperm whales are killed every year. Sea Shephard opposes whaling and refers to its rights under the UN World Charter for Nature which allows NGOs to take action to protect animal species.
 
New campaign
Meanwhile Sea Shephard is about to embark on a new campaign against whaling. It is important to be cautious, thinks the organisation. But: "We are going ahead. That is for certain," says Mr Vons. It is still not clear what the Japanese whalers plan to do:
 
"Maybe they’ll decide not to go hunting this time. You never know. But for sure Sea Shepherd will never stop until the illegal whaling has stopped."
 
The campaign against whaling in Antarctic waters starts in December.
 
See Sea Shepherd footage below:

 

  • Geert Vons director of Sea Shepherd - Willemien Groot/RNW
    Geert Vons director of Sea Shepherd - Willemien Groot/RNW
  • Fred Soons, maritime law expert - Willemien Groot/RNW
    Fred Soons, maritime law expert - Willemien Groot/RNW
  • Sea Shepherd ship Steve Irwin - Witty lama/Wikipedia
    Sea Shepherd ship Steve Irwin - Witty lama/Wikipedia
<< >>

Discussion

Liza 24 November 2009 - 7:27pm / Brazil
Pitty there aren't 1.000 Sea Shepherds around. The Japanese are going too far and, unfortunatelly, the Dutch government is bending under the pressure.
Bryan Richardson 22 November 2009 - 6:32am / USA
Wow...how noble...so it's wrong to kill whales but racism is perfectly acceptable? "slant eyed pusssies should be turned into fish food themselves or better yet,soilent green to feed their hungry masses!" "HEY SAILORBOB WHAT YOUR COMMENT WOULD BE IF YOUR SKIN WILL BE HUNTED BY THOSE DEVILS IN THE NAME OF THE "RESEARCH"? HUH?" Way to take the moral high ground there fellas... And PLEASE let's not even attempt to kid ourselves by comparing Paul Watson with Ghandi or M.L. King Jr. These men stood for non-violent resistance and that is what made them successful. Paul Watson most certainly does not, and that is what will continue to make him unsuccessful. "Returning violence for violence multiplies violence, adding deeper darkness to a night already devoid of stars... Hate cannot drive out hate: only love can do that." Martin Luther King Jr. "Violence breeds violence...Pure goals can never justify impure or violent action...They say the means are after all just means. I would say means are after all everything. As the means, so the end....If we take care of the means we are bound of reach the end sooner or later." M.K. GANDHI
Lena 20 November 2009 - 8:34am / Australia
HAHA Oh man that made me laugh seeing the title of that Japanese You Tube Video "Attempted Murder By Sea Shepherd" what a laugh. They haven't killed anyone in the 30 years they have been operating as opposed to the Japanese whaling fleet, who had a fatality just this year within their fleet, a whaler overboard which Sea Shepherd actually joined the search in trying to help the Japanese find this man .! I have a sneaking suspicion this cabinet member has been offered a bit of payola from the Japanese. The Japanese have tried every other angle to shut Sea Shepherd down and none of these angles have worked and all of a sudden this person pops up...how peculiar and pathetic that the money is the ruler of all in this day and age.
AnakinG 19 November 2009 - 6:53pm
Maybe Japan will stop whaling once all racist remarks from so-called convervationists are gone. I think the goal of whale conservationist now is to eliminate racism among their own peers.
ThisGuy 18 November 2009 - 7:15pm
The Dutch government must come to common sense...SSCS are terrorists who wish to cause serious harm to the Japanese whalers. None of whom have committed any crime. The Dutch government should not allow people to exercise terrorism against Japan. They must stop these eco-terrorists before they commit truly harmful acts as they have shown in the past.
whythehate 18 November 2009 - 2:25pm
No one believes whaling is right. Just delicious.
Anonymous 18 November 2009 - 2:22pm
If you want to stop whaling...have lawmakers take away the japanese research permits through peaceful methods. You can't get it done through violent acts and racist comments.
AnakinG 18 November 2009 - 2:21am
so, unless you are actually racist, you should refrain from attacking Japanese people in general in a racist ways. Makes the rest of whale conservationists look racist as well. Just so you know, a strange sense of nationalism supporting whaling is growing in Japan because of all the name calling and personal attacks of few moronic conservationsts.
Neptune 18 November 2009 - 12:28am
The Netherlands should be backing the sea shepherds not oppressing them They have signed a treaty to protect the whales from exactly what the Japaneses are doing.Killing whales for food.Whaling is a blood sport they run the whales down over many kilometers before they shoot them then they drag the Whales backwards till it suffocates.Bloodsports are banned in the Netherlands and to ban the sea shepherd is a slap in the face to democracy!
get it straight 18 November 2009 - 2:46pm
Their whaling is not illegal because it's not "commercial" whaling. It is "research" whaling. Doesn't make it right, but it's legal.
vaalea 20 November 2009 - 5:53pm / Canada
Research... such a great excuse to torture and kill animals legally. "At this weekend's International Whaling Commission in London, the Australian delegation plans to argue for the end of a loophole that allows taking whales for scientific research, the Sydney Daily Telegraph reported. Nick Gales, the head of the Australian scientific delegation, said that a review of Japanese research found that scientists have published only 43 papers in 18 years, which he called "an incredibly low publication rate." Papers on whale mortality contained such wide margins of error that they were useless, he added. Japanese scientists have also performed what Gales called "really bizarre" experiments like injecting Minke whale sperm into cow eggs." http://www.physorg.com/news124172569.html It's a farce, and we are calling it what it is, commercial whaling, not "research" as claimed.
Zlatko Colovic 17 November 2009 - 1:13pm
SailorBob is bat. He doesn't know which species is going to win, so he is fighting for currently prevailing one. That is why SailorBobs are living in caves, hiding from everybody. But still, they go out sometimes, to drink blood of sleeping animals. Because they can not really fight for food, you know..
SailorBob 14 November 2009 - 1:51am
Look. If the whales are endangered, it's because they can't adapt. Survival of the fittest. So far, humans seem to be the fittest. We've adapted to all environments (including underwater and space). If the whales go the way of the dodo so be it.
HougaHouga 15 November 2009 - 10:34pm
Wow Sailerbob you are an exemple of so called thinking human ! Sure, human discover lot things on belhalf of cupidity, but for what ? what are the real needs ? for making you happy sure ! Hoping you are ! When you will discover your brain let me know !
person 13 November 2009 - 9:03pm
human need urgent limits to protect animals from our greed EVOLUTION
Pubcrawler 13 November 2009 - 5:25am
Sometimes change requires a little civil disobedience, Right? Gandhi? M.L. King? Solidarity? Paul Watson?
Pubcrawler 13 November 2009 - 5:25am
Sometimes change requires a little civil disobedience, Right? Gandhi? M.L. King? Solidarity? Paul Watson?
captkit 13 November 2009 - 1:59am
Hey Dutch. I'm Third generation American, Grandfolks from Finland and Sweden. 37, ooo underwater. Army Vet. In world of wars caused stupidity. Sea Shepard is doing a great job about some of the bad things going on ,currently on this planet. As we respect your country and flag.Please may you continue use it for what is "RIGHT" !!! Are nations you have trade agreements with allowed to kill for profit when it is not necessary.So you must agree.What do they offer you that cause you to say its ok to kill endanger species.
Brendan Maas 12 November 2009 - 7:05pm
I agree with Ridgewolf 13. This world is over-populated, instead of slaughtering the minimal amount of whales we still have left, lets cull these ignorant Japs. Wish the U.S would have finished the job in the 40's. All these people do is ravage the worlds environment and species that inhabit them. Then use their economic power to threaten countries into submission. The world is over-populated, we could do without Japan and China, and kill two birds with one stone. Cull the human population by more then 2 billion people, and save countless invaluable species and the environment from these ignorant and arogant countries!!!!!
captkit 13 November 2009 - 2:14am
First come radical Muslims, they want the world. However they will feed infidels to the ocean creatures. Truly, I would like all nations to fight the radical Muslim threat. The certainly would not like to meet a true Samarai like those who came before Hatsumi a True Legend of Japan. Who didn,t kill whales.
Zlatko Colovic 12 November 2009 - 1:42pm
Nonsense. The list of priorities seems to be lost somewhere in Dutch government offices- they should look for it, because The Life of Earth is number one on that list, as it always should and must be there, as the matter of our biggest Concern- no Earth, no Us, remember? Current monetary security, or whatever that quickly changeable variable might be called, comes only .after. the first one. It still amazes me that in 21 Century, after (or with?) who-knows-how-much experience in Science field Humans have, there are still some basic issues absolutely neglected by our lonely, beautiful planet (intelligent part)- Steve Irwin is not the first ship fighting for Life on Earth, but there is still nothing, nowhere, mentioning 'registration-free' option- one (every!) vessel of such importance .must. be issued with flag of planet Earth, one which will provide free-access permits to every single port existing, without visas for it's Crew, without politic background following (but mostly intercepting!) it's actions- but not to go into other subjects here- Dutch government, .any. government, should be P.roud for it's flag to flap from the mast of one ship like SSCS Steve Irwin!
Anonymous 12 November 2009 - 8:14am
"Japan says it hunts whales for scientific research. Around 1000 minke whales, blue whales and sperm whales are killed every year." Please give some information sources that BLUE WHALES are killed by Japan every year. I hope you to deal with information correctly.
Ted 12 November 2009 - 6:18am
Don't be fooled by the politicians - No government can legally do anything (on the international level) as long as the Japanese have these legal permits. Since the IWC is the governing body that officially recognizes the Southern Sanctuary AND is also the organization the issue the 'research' permits, the Japanese can't be picked up by Interpol, as they can produce the proper permits. Australia can nab them for breaking their local laws, but only if they enter the 3 mile nautical jurisdiction of Australia. You have to cut the problem off at the head. Pressure the IWC to stop giving the Japanese a free 'research' pass, and then countries can throw sanctions at them. Until then, they will continue to say "hey, if it was wrong, we would not be able to get the permits" and continue killing whales. The end of whaling will not come from ramming ships - it will come from the re-vamping of the IWC rules and tightening of the definition of 'research'. "slant eyed pussies" - Really, RidgeWolf13, is racism necessary? I'm sure the Japanese translators and other asians that work for Sea Shepherd and Greenpeace truly appreciate your mocking of their physical characteristics and lack of courage, especially since they are risking not only their livelihoods but those of their entire families by taking up arms for another country against their own government's organizations. In most countries, that's called treason. If you want to call the whalers unresasonable blood-mongering monsters, that's fine, but don't degrade yourself by being racist - you're better than that.
thank you 18 November 2009 - 3:12pm
Thank you. Well defined.
SailorBob 12 November 2009 - 5:31am
Actually, killing whales is not murder as some suggest. Killing people is. If I were to meet the crew of the Steve Irwin I would do whatever I could to make sure they never tried to ram another ship again. The crew of the Steve Irwin are nothing but pirates and their criminal acts should (at least) land them in prison or they should go be sunk themselves. Whales are just animals.
Anonymous 13 December 2009 - 1:43am / USA
From one sailor to another, we both know the Steve Irwin (SI) crew is a bunch of pirates. If i were a Japanese official, I would tell the Dutch government that since the SI sails under the Dutch flag, they have committed an act of war against a Japanese vessel. I have never really supported the killing of whales until I saw Whale Wars and saw the kind of maniacs on board the SI. Thanks, Sea Shepherds! You have changed my attitude completely. Now i realize...WHALES ARE FOOD!!! As a general rule, humans are higher on the food-chain, therefore, bring on the sushi.
ANTI MONSTERS 21 November 2009 - 1:57am / US
HEY SAILORBOB WHAT YOUR COMMENT WOULD BE IF YOUR SKIN WILL BE HUNTED BY THOSE DEVILS IN THE NAME OF THE "RESEARCH"? HUH? IS OUTRAGEOUS WHAT THOSE MONSTERS ARE DOING. THEY HAVE TO INFLICT PAIN ON ANYTHING THAT BREATHS INCLUDING ON THEMSELVES. THEY ARE NOT HUMANS, AND THEY ARE SO MANY!
Marko Ivezic 12 November 2009 - 2:12pm
"Dear Sailor", if you just look through some of the books concerning the elementary education, you'll see that the humans are animals, too. Except, we came a long after these creatures you call animals. Lets take a look at this scenario. You live somewhere, minding your own business, living your life... And suddenly, I come as an advanced creature and just because you're on a lower level I kill you. How would you feel if that's the way life goes on. It wouldn't feel nice, right? So, my point is, although it seems that you're on a higher level of development, you're not. The same whale wouldn't kill you for fun and so it could make some money! Kill is a kill, no matter what species are involved! So as long as there are people defending the rights of those who can't do that for themselves, they'll have my support! Without killing any of animals including humans too!
SailorBob 14 November 2009 - 3:22am
Marko - "You live somewhere, minding your own business, living your life... And suddenly, I come as an advanced creature and just because you're on a lower level I kill you. How would you feel if that's the way life goes on." Excellent. You just described something we call nature. When a lion kills a zebra, a stronger animal kills a weaker one. Been going on for, well, as long as there was life. Maybe you need to read some of your "elementary education" books again. Or, better yet, watch a National Geographic show.
Zlatko Colovic 17 November 2009 - 1:06pm
No, undear 'SailorBob'. What Mr. Marko have explained to you is that YOU are a Zebra, in this case. The way of living, which you have embraced (I'd say proudly?) is based on same principles as in Animal World, but, undear 'SailorBob' (who, and for which reasons, is hiding his name? are you a bird, or a mammal, you- bat!), we are still few levels, or better to say ~plains~, above those with whom are we to be coincided, here in your case only. Grow up, and learn something from National Geographic, for which you claim you are watching. It is there to .make you. advance, not to keep you like you are now.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <p> <br>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

Mollom CAPTCHA (play audio CAPTCHA)
Type the characters you see in the picture above; if you can't read them, submit the form and a new image will be generated.


Video highlights

Moroccan beekeepers: a joint loan reduces risk
Beekeepers in Morocco don't like working on their own. If they join forces...
This week in the Netherlands
Captain Marco Kroon was recognized by Queen Beatrix for his bravery in...
China speaks loudly and carries a big stick
China has suddenly adopted a harsher and more threatening tone towards the...
Microcredit gives Comfort a helping hand
Microcredit is slowly helping to transform Comfort Azelima's life. She...

Music programmes





Newsletter

Dutch and international news roundup, distributed daily at 16.00 UTC. Please click the link and send the email message.

Dutch Press Review: of the leading Dutch newspapers every weekday.

Programme preview. What's on guide. Please click the link and send the email message.

Media Network Newsletter, published each Thursday. You can find daily updates on the Media Network Weblog.

Euro Hit 40, monthly newsletter about Europe's No. 1 chart show with Tim Fisher

RNW - NEWS, ANALYSIS AND BACKGROUND IN 10 LANGUAGES, WORLDWIDE 24 HOURS A DAY, ON RADIO, TELEVISION AND THE INTERNET