Radio Netherlands Worldwide

SSO Login

More login possibilities:

Close
  • Facebook
  • Flickr
  • Twitter
  • Google
  • LinkedIn
Home
Friday 25 May RNW - NEWS AND ANALYSIS FROM THE NETHERLANDS IN 10 LANGUAGES, WORLDWIDE 24/7 ON RADIO, TV AND ONLINE
condoms
Belinda van Steijn's picture
Map
Vatican City, Vatican
Vatican City, Vatican

Cautious reactions to new Vatican condom stance

Published on : 22 November 2010 - 7:10pm | By Belinda van Steijn (photo: Flickr/Chepe Nicoli)
More about:

"I'm waiting until a priest tells us which way to go" says a Kenyan catholic. There have been cautious reactions around the world to Pope Benedict XVI's statement that the use of condoms is acceptable in some cases.

Previously, the pope has always totally rejected the use of contraceptives. But in a recent interview with German journalist Peter Seewald, Benedict was less categorical: using condoms is permissible in some individual situations. He was referring primarily to people infected with the AIDS virus HIV.

Difficult
Moniek van der Kroef of the Dutch organisation Aidsfonds regards the pope's remarks as a breath of fresh air:

"I think it will help people with AIDS and those who are at risk. Now they're hearing they're allowed to use condoms in some cases. It means condoms can no longer be ruled out, that you can keep them around and make use of them in a more relaxed way. In some countries they've made condoms an immensely difficult topic."

No comment
In Kenya the news about the pope's volte-face has been covered in the newspapers and on radio and television. The official institutions have not yet commented. Nor has the website run by the Gay and Lesbian Coalition of Kenya. Churches and theologians have been silent so far. They are waiting for an official reaction from Cardinal John Jeu, the archbishop of Nairobi.

The Roman Catholic Church has a great deal of influence in Kenya but, in private conversations, priests have been advocating the use of contraceptives for some time.

Furore
In the Kenyan daily The Standard the reaction of churchgoers has been largely stoical: "I heard it on the news but no one has given their opinion, so I'll wait until the priest tells us which way to go." says one. Another opines: "The pope would never take decisions that are bad for the church or the faithful. He must have good reasons."

Benedict caused a furore last year on a trip to Africa, when he said that handing out condoms was not the solution to the problem of AIDS. Even now he says condoms are not the way to combat HIV/AIDS but that their use is sometimes permissible.

Wilderness
"Too little too late" is the reaction of Brazilian liberation theologian and former priest Leonardo Boff:

"Never, and I mean never, in thousands of confessions have I heard anyone confess to the sin of using a condom. In practice Christians have not followed the pope's message. The pope's voice was a voice in the wilderness, completely at odds with normal practices."

Leonardo Boff was repeatedly called to order by the Vatican for criticising the church. In the end he renounced the priesthood.

Compassionate
So is this a revolution in the Catholic church? Not really, says Dutch priest and historian Antoine Bodar, since other clergymen have spoken out in favour of condoms. But it is good that the pope has now personally sanctioned a less rigid course.

"The church is displaying its compassionate side and showing that it is not so hidebound. In theory the church would like to achieve the ideal situation, but in practice that doesn't always succeed. So the church believes that people with AIDS should of course use condoms."

Discussion

Hiram2 23 November 2010 - 4:23pm

"The Vatican, as ever, moving at the break-neck speed of a tectonic plate."....JW, the seismograph of the Catholic Church. The Church not moving fast enough for you, JW?

JW 24 November 2010 - 3:31pm / NL

Indeed, the Vatican moves a bit too slow for my tastes. I suspect a bit too slow for Galileo also, in accepting that the world revolves around the sun. To slow for Darwin too, in accepting human evolution (as John Paul did in '96). But perhaps most distressingly, too slow for anyone presently dying from AIDS who had avoided condoms for religious reasons.

Hiram2 24 November 2010 - 4:24pm

JW, I agree with you, mate! Only problem is: Those who are dying from AIDS should not be having sex. One is dying from AIDS and that person still wants to have sex and kill other humans by passing on the death sentence!

JW 24 November 2010 - 6:02pm / NL

Many people can be HIV positive and have no symptoms yet. Testing isn't even available for much of the world's population. So telling people who are at death's door to stop having unprotected sex is rather insufficient. The promotion of condom use is an excellent first step in preventing the spread of AIDS. Preaching against their use is counterproductive to the goal of eradicating this disease.

Hiram2 24 November 2010 - 8:45pm

JW, people who dying from AIDS, should not be be having and sex and spreading it. I was not preaching against the use of condoms. I was making it known that people who are "dying" should not help some other person get AIDS. This is one of the reasons AIDS is on the rise in Amsterdam. People let their lust for sex override any common sense.

JW 25 November 2010 - 10:09am / NL

Agreed. The Vatican is an insular dinosaur with little connection to the real world.

JW 23 November 2010 - 11:47am / NL

The Vatican, as ever, moving at the break-neck speed of a tectonic plate.

Post new comment

Please be reminded all comments must be in English, short and to the point - guideline 250 words. Abusive and inappropriate comments will be removed.

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <p> <br>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

Video highlights

Dutch beachcombers: a dying breed
Dutch beachcombers are a dying breed. In the past, objects would regularly...
Shell presented with "Oily Mary" cocktail from Niger Delta
Friends of the Earth Netherlands has offered "Oily Mary"...

RNW on Facebook

Sign up for our newsletters

Email news bulletin

What's on - Programme Preview

Press Review - of the leading Dutch newspapers every weekday

Media Network

Euro Hit 40 - Europe's No. 1 chart show

RNW - News and analysis from the Netherlands in 10 languages, worldwide 24/7 on radio, television and online